The Heir Is Chosen
Nobody ever chose me. I want that at the front of this chapter because the family has told it the other way round ever since, as though there had been an evening and a decision and somebody saying her name, and there was not. There was no evening. I have gone back over it more carefully than I have gone back over anything else in my life and I cannot find a day on which it happened, and the reason I cannot find one is that it did not happen on a day. It accumulated.
It went like this. I counted, and everybody knew I counted, and so when something needed counting it came to me, and having come to me once it came to me again. I did the nails at six. I did the greens bed at eight. At eleven I was doing the household’s whole year — what we grew, what we caught, what we ate, what went over — and reading the figures out at the table on the first Sunday of the month to two people who were too tired to check them and did not need to. At fourteen our mother mentioned, in the same tone she used for the weather, that the depot had nobody who could keep a stock book and that I might walk down with her on a Tuesday and see what I made of it. That was the entire ceremony. I made a great deal of it, because it was numbers and there were a lot of them, and I went back on the Thursday, and I was still going thirty-nine years later.
By eighteen it was simply what I did, and by twenty-two, when the pen came down the table to me on the night of Cass’s line and again on the night of Piper’s, it was what everybody understood I was for. And I had never once agreed to any of it. That is not a complaint and I would not have made it out loud at the time. It is an accounting term. There had been no offer and therefore there had been no acceptance, and the whole edifice was standing on a transaction that had never taken place.
Then came the August after my sister’s clear, and the forty pounds of greens going to slime at the end of the bed, and the thing I have already set down — standing at the fence line at twenty-four understanding that the line was mine. I have been careful with the word mine ever since. It did not mean I had taken it. It meant that of all the things wrong with the valley, this was the one whose shape was the same shape as the inside of my head, and that a person who has spent sixteen years counting exactly how much food a family throws away is not a person who can look at that line and see somebody else’s problem. Recognising a thing is yours and agreeing to be spent on it are two different transactions, and the whole of the following year went into finding out whether the second one could be declined.
I did it the only way I know how to do anything, which was to make a list and put numbers against it. I did not tell anybody I was doing it. I took the back pages of the ledger, which had been mine since I was nine and which by then had fifteen years of my handwriting in them, and I ruled out a fresh sheet and wrote the twelve lines that were left across the top of it, and underneath each one I put three things: what a person would have to become to strike it, how many years that would take starting from nothing, and who in Glassbolt could teach them. The third column is the one that did the damage. It was very nearly empty.
Books wanted a person who could write one, in a valley with nothing to read and nobody who had ever been taught how. The walls wanted a painter and there was no paint. The instrument line wanted somebody who could play, and there was not an instrument inside the cordon that I knew of, and no one living who could have shown a beginner where to put their hands. The sky wanted something I could not even put a trade to; I wrote ? in all three columns and sat looking at it for a while. Heavy lifting wanted a body, and I had the wrong one. The small children wanted a person who would spend their life minding other people’s infants, and I want to be honest here and say that I looked at that line for a long time and did not want it, and that not wanting it made me ashamed and did not make me want it. The line about nobody being able to take leave or change their trade or stop wanted somebody who could stand at the front of other people’s working lives for thirty years without once being ill, and I put a mark against it and moved on, because I had watched what the depot did to my mother in four days out of seven.
There were four I could genuinely have gone at. The shops, because I understood stock and a shop is stock with a door on it. The money that could not be kept, which was arithmetic of a sort, though of a sort that would have taken me somewhere I did not like the look of. The contact with the outside, which wanted a person willing to spend thirty years becoming something I had no name for and no route into. And somewhere to sit down and stay, which my sister had pushed back across the table and said was not hers and which I had privately thought, that Sunday, might be mine — right up until I put the numbers against it and found that I would be learning hospitality from nobody, in a valley with no room to do it in, and that I would be forty-four before anybody could sit anywhere.
And against every single one of them I had to write the same figure in the second column, which was the number of years it would cost to start from nothing, and the same figure against the selling line, which was four. Four, because I had been doing it since I was six. Not because I was gifted — I want to be extremely clear that I was not, and that the whole legend of this afterward is wrong — but because a trade is mostly a quantity of ordinary hours and I had already done sixteen years of mine before anybody thought to call it a trade. The valley had been charging me for the apprenticeship since before I could read.
So the sheet said what the sheet said. If I took the selling line the valley got it in four years. If I took anything else the valley got that thing in twenty-odd, got the selling line whenever somebody else could be found for it, and in the meantime went on being a place where a family could grow more food than it could eat and still put a child through a winter in her brother’s boots. I checked the sheet three times over three separate evenings, hoping to have made an error, which is the only time in my life I have ever hoped that.
Then I tried to give it away, which is the part of that year I have never told anybody about except the two people involved. There were three of us left unspent — myself, Odell, and Bly, both of them twenty and me twenty-four — and it seemed to me that if the line was going to take a life it ought at least to take one that had put its hand up. I went to Bly first because Bly was easy to talk to, which in that family meant he answered questions.
He was sitting on the step doing what he did most evenings, which was lifting the same four bricks off the ground and setting them down again. He heard the whole proposition out and then said no, without any of the softening a person usually puts round a no, and when I asked him why he said that he had been carried places until he was nine and that he could still remember the exact way people arranged their arms to do it. Then he said the other thing, which I did not properly hear at the time. He said that heavy was not something he was going to grow out of and that he had stopped waiting to, and that he had decided at about fifteen that if he was never going to be a big man he would settle for being a strong one, and that there was a line on that page about things too heavy for one person staying where they fell, and that it had had his name on it in his own head for five years.
I went back into the house afterward and sat down and had to reorganise a number of things. My brother had chosen a line, privately, at fifteen, and had told nobody, and had been going out to the step every evening for five years to lift bricks in front of a family that had all separately decided he was doing it because he was small. I had counted that house every way it could be counted. I had the yields and the stock and the nails and the pears, and I had not known the most important fact about one of the five people in it. It was the first indication I ever had that counting is not the same as knowing, and I took it badly, and I have never entirely stopped taking it badly.
So I went to Odell, and this is the conversation I would take back if I were allowed to take one back.
He was round the back of the second room with a stick, which by then I had stopped seeing, in the way you stop seeing a thing that has been there since the person was four. I put it to him plainly: that the selling line was going to take somebody, that I was the obvious somebody and did not want to be, that he was twenty and unspent, and that if he wanted it I would stand at that table and say so and not take it back. I was offering him a career I had worked out on paper. I thought I was being generous. I have had forty years to look at what I was actually doing, which was walking up to the one person in that family nobody had ever asked a question of and asking him whether he would like to take mine.
He did not look up from the ground. He said, “I’ll take whatever’s left,” and went on with what he was doing.
I took it for agreeableness. That is the whole of my defence and it is not much of one. Odell was the easiest of the five of us to be in a room with and the least trouble to anybody, and I heard a mild young man decline an offer politely and I wrote it down in my head as O: no preference and went on to the next thing on my list. It was eleven years before I understood that he had answered me exactly, in five words, and that what he had said was that he had been standing at the back of the queue since he was four and had worked out the rules of it long before I had, and that the rule was that things came to him after everybody else had chosen. He was not being agreeable. He was reporting a finding. It was the same kind of sentence I made my whole life out of and I did not recognise it because it was not about nails.
But I want to put the worse thing down as well, because this is an account and not a defence. I had noticed the Sunday. I had sat at that table and watched thirteen lines be read out and watched the one about the walls go past fifth in the list in my mother’s stock-count voice and watched my brother not move, and I had thought, at the time, clearly, in words: nobody has asked him. I did not raise it that night because it was Piper’s night. I did not raise it in the autumn because I was three weeks into my own sheet of paper and did not want to widen the problem. And by the spring I had a reason that sounded better than either, which was that Odell had told me himself that he had no preference. I built that reason out of five words he had given me while looking at the ground, and I used it for eleven years, and it held perfectly well because nobody ever tested it.
In the February I did the thing I had been circling since August, which was to go to my mother and ask her to tell me to do it.
I did not dress it up either. She was sixty-seven and in the chair by then for most of the evening, and I sat down on the crate opposite her with the sheet in my hand and said that I had run the whole of it, that the answer was four years against twenty-odd, that I could not find a way round it, and that I wanted her to say it. Not to advise. To say it. I told her that if she told me to take the selling line I would take it in the morning and never raise it again, and that I was asking her for that as a favour and she should understand it as one.
She would not. She sat there and looked at the sheet and did not take it out of my hand, and said that she had done that arithmetic about me before I was born and had promised in the dark that I would never hear it out of her, and that she had kept it for twenty-five years at a cost she was not going to itemise, and that she was not going to break it at the last for the convenience of letting me off. She said one more thing. She said: “If I tell you, it’s mine. You’ll do it well and you’ll do it angry and in thirty years you’ll be sitting in this chair and it will still be mine. I’m not doing that to you.”
I was furious with her for about four years and I never once said so, which in that house passed for a conversation. Because an order I could have refused. An order would have been a thing standing in front of me with edges on it, and I had spent my whole life putting numbers against things with edges, and I would have known what to do with it in an afternoon. What she gave me instead was a silence with my own arithmetic sitting in the middle of it, and there is no way to push back against a person who has declined to push. I understand it now and I understood it then, in the way you understand a thing you are not yet willing to give credit for. It was the single most generous act of my mother’s life and it was indistinguishable, from where I was sitting, from being left in a room on my own.
Cass found me at the fence line in the March, which was where the family went when it did not want to be in the house, and I told him the whole of it because he was the one person who had already been through the far side of the same door. He listened to it leaning on the post with his arms folded and did not offer an opinion, because he never did. Then he asked me the question he had been asking the valley since he was twenty, except that he had taken it apart and put it back together for me, and what he said was: “Suited isn’t the same as asked. Is it.”
I said that it was not. He said that was the whole of what he had wanted somebody to say to him at sixteen, and that nobody had, and that he had gone on asking it at a fence for four years and had never once been given anything back except that everyone agreed he had been very useful. He said he was not going to tell me what to do either, and that he wanted me to notice that he was the second person that month to refuse, and that the reason both of us were refusing was that we had each been handed a life by people who meant well and had no idea they were doing it. Then he said that if I did take it, I should take it out loud, where somebody could hear me, because it was the only part of the whole business anybody in our family had ever been able to control.
The last person I went to was Piper, because she was the only one of us who had ever stood up and chosen a thing in front of witnesses and then gone and done it. I walked up to the Halt on a wet afternoon in April and stood at the end of her counter in the rain until the queue thinned, and she gave me something hot without asking whether I wanted it, which was the entire method of her life, and then leaned on the trestle with the scarred arm out on the boards where it always was and said, “Go on.”
I gave her the sheet. She read it the way she read everything, which was fast and only once, and handed it back and said that she could not see the problem. I said the problem was that I had not chosen it. And my sister — who was twenty-one, who had been used up at twenty, who was standing in the rain under a leaking canopy with a burn from her wrist to her elbow — said that she had not chosen hers either, that she had walked up a road in March to get boots and the trade had closed over her before anybody knew it was happening, and that the only difference between us was that she had found out afterward and I was being made to find out in advance. “You think being asked would have made it better,” she said. “It would have made it yours. That’s not the same thing and it’s not nicer. I’d have liked to be asked. I’d have said yes and then I’d have had to live with having said it.”
And all the way through that year — the whole eleven months of not deciding — I was at the depot six days a week doing the work. I want that on the page because it is the actual shape of what happened and it is not flattering. I was not sitting in a room refusing. I was keeping the stock book and reorganising the intake and working out, because it interested me, what the depot would need to hold if a person could one day walk in and buy a sack of something rather than wait for a Tuesday. I started a second sheet in the back of the ledger that autumn about how a trade in this valley might actually be built, and it ran to nine pages by the spring, and every single one of them was in the handwriting of a woman who had spent the same nine pages telling everybody she had not agreed to anything.
I noticed it in the May, at the depot, in the middle of a Thursday, holding a pencil. There was nothing dramatic about the moment and I have never been able to make it sound like anything. I was halfway down a column when it arrived, complete, the way Piper’s arithmetic arrived rather than mine: that the decision had been taken some months earlier by a person doing ordinary work in an ordinary week, and that it had not required an act of will at any point, and that I had spent the better part of a year conducting an inquiry into a question that the hours had already answered. That is how it is done in this family. Nobody chooses anything. They simply keep turning up at the thing until the thing has them, and then afterward everyone says there was an evening.
So I did the one part of it Cass said could be controlled. I walked home that evening and did not go in. I went down to the fence line at the bottom of the ground, where the greens bed ended and the flood plain started and where I had stood the previous August watching forty pounds of food go over, and I said it out loud, in a normal voice, to nobody: that I would take the selling line, that I was taking it because it was four years and not twenty, that nobody had asked me and I had decided to consider myself asked, and that I was not doing it for the family and was not doing it for my mother and was doing it because I had counted that waste since I was eight and I was not going to spend the rest of my life watching it and calling it somebody else’s.
There was nobody within four hundred yards of me. It was the single most consequential sentence of my life and it was heard by a fence, a ditch, and a great deal of grey ground, and I understood as I was saying it that this was going to be the case and said it anyway, because a thing said out loud to nobody is still a thing you cannot afterward claim you never said. I went in and had my supper. I did not tell my mother for two months and when I did she said, “Right,” and asked me what I thought the depot would need, and we talked about the depot until eleven o’clock.
That night I took the ledger and turned it over and opened it at the back, where my own list had been running since I was nine, and I put the year’s work in it: the twelve lines, the three columns, the nine pages about the trade, and at the bottom of the last of them the sentence I had said at the fence, written down in full because I did not trust myself to remember having said it. Then I turned the book the right way up and left it open at the front the way it lived, with the tag across the fold and my mother’s fourteen and my own two entries under it in a hand that was nothing like hers. There was a gap of about ninety blank pages between the two ends of that book. I was twenty-five years old and I had four years of work in front of me and a brother behind me with a stick and no paper, and I did not look at the gap that night, and I have looked at it most nights since.
Simmers!
If you’re interested in writing and/or reading sims stories, participating in fun competitions and events, joining a friendly and welcoming community, completing legacies and challenge and earning medals, or just having a great place to discuss Sims 2, Sims 3, or Sims 4, then there is a place for you at the
Boolprop.net Forums
Discover more from Love My Sims
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Be the first to comment