Mateo’s Chapter 17

I didn’t notice the organ was gone at first.

The house had been shifting around me for weeks—new rhythms, new routines, new sounds—so one more absence didn’t register right away. It wasn’t until I walked past the corner where it used to sit, the place where the air always felt a little heavier, a little more charged, that I realized the space was empty.

“Where is it?” I asked Lilith later.

She didn’t look up from the bottle she was warming. “Safe.”

“Safe where?”

“Just… safe.”

She didn’t elaborate.
I didn’t push.
But something in my chest tightened anyway.

The house had changed.
I was still learning how to fit inside it.


Lucian came home from school sick two days later—feverish, pale, moving slowly in that stubborn way kids do when they don’t want to admit they feel awful. His fever rose and fell for days, never quite breaking, never quite settling.

He still tried to do his homework, but only if Lionel sat beside him.
Only if Lionel read the questions out loud.
Only if Lionel reminded him to stay focused.

He was holding a C average, inching toward a B, but the missing assignments were dragging him down.

I offered to help once.

Lucian smiled—polite, grateful—but he said, “It’s okay. Lionel knows how the teacher explains it.”

And that was that.

I wasn’t hurt.
Not exactly.
But something in me folded in on itself, quiet and small.


Nova was getting bigger every day—rounder cheeks, steadier hands, brighter eyes. She’d outgrow her crib soon, and I found myself savoring every moment before that happened. Holding her. Rocking her. Letting her fall asleep against my shoulder while her breath warmed the side of my neck.

She didn’t cling the way Thalia did.
She didn’t push away the way Selene sometimes did.
She just… existed with me.

Curious.
Calm.
Learning me piece by piece.

Those moments felt like gifts I hadn’t earned.


Selene was different.

Some mornings she’d lift her arms for me, soft and warm and sleepy, letting me hold her for a few precious seconds before she wriggled free. Other mornings she’d stop short when she saw me—eyes wide, breath quick, body tense.

But she wasn’t hitting me anymore.
She wasn’t crying when I walked into the room.
She wasn’t clinging to Lionel like I was a shadow she needed protection from.

I hadn’t been in my dark form once since waking.
I wasn’t going to risk that.

And slowly—carefully—she was starting to believe I was safe.

Those were the sweetest days.


The best day came when all three girls were happy at the same time—laughing, babbling, climbing over me like I was part of the furniture. Thalia telling jokes that made no sense. Selene showing me a book she couldn’t read yet. Nova patting my cheek like she was checking to make sure I was real.

For the first time since waking, the house felt… full.
Not overwhelming.
Not foreign.
Just full.


I told Lilith it was time for Nova to move to the toddler bed, and she nodded.

“Go ahead.”

So I did.

I set up the bed.
I moved her toys.
I showed her the new room.
And she took her first steps toward me that same afternoon—wobbly, determined, reaching for my hands.

I taught her how to balance.
How to shift her weight.
How to trust her feet.

I started her potty training the next day.

With Nova in the toddler room, the girls began gathering there for everything—playtime, storytime, potty time. The room felt alive in a way it never had before.

The first night in her new bed, Nova pointed at the book on the nightstand and said, “Tay-oh.”

Read to me.

So I did.

She fell asleep before I finished the second page.


Later, I told Lilith I was happy.

She smiled—small, real. “Good.”

Things were starting to feel normal.
Or at least, a version of normal I could live inside.

We even watched a movie all the way through one night. The toddlers slept better now, and the house was quiet in a way it hadn’t been since before the twins were born.

Lilith was due any day.
The peace wouldn’t last.

But for the first time, I wasn’t afraid of what came next


We made it almost halfway through the movie before things shifted. Lilith leaned into my side, her hand brushing my arm in that way she does when she’s feeling playful. I glanced at her, and she gave me that small, knowing smile — the one that always hits me low in the stomach.

I slid my hand over hers.

She raised an eyebrow.

And then Lionel, from the other end of the couch, said, “Are you two… flirting?”

Lilith didn’t even look at him. “Lionel.”

“What? I’m just saying—”

“Go to bed,” I said, trying not to laugh.

He groaned dramatically, then laughed anyway. “Fine, fine. I know when I’m not wanted.”

He stretched, cracked his back like an old man, and headed upstairs. We listened to his footsteps fade down the hall.

The moment the house settled into silence, I leaned toward Lilith, ready to kiss her.

Of course that’s when she gasped and grabbed the arm of the couch.

“Lilith?”

She breathed out slowly. “It’s time.”

The movie kept playing, oblivious. She stood, already focused, already shifting into that calm, efficient mode she always had during labor. She headed upstairs toward the nursery without another word.

I turned off the lights, checked the doors, made sure everything was quiet — pointless tasks, but they kept my hands busy. By the time I reached the nursery, she was gripping the edge of the bassinet, breathing through another contraction.

I moved toward her instinctively, hands out, ready to help.

“Mateo,” she warned.

“I’m just—”

“Sit.”

“But—”

“Sit.”

I sat.

She paced.
She breathed.
She handled it the way she always did — steady, focused, unshakable.

Every time she winced, I flinched.
Every time she breathed out, I held mine.
Every time she shifted her weight, I was halfway out of the chair before she shot me a look that put me right back down.

And then, suddenly, it was over.

A small cry filled the room — thin, new, perfect.

Lilith lifted him, exhausted but glowing in that fierce, quiet way she always had after birth. She placed him in my arms, and everything in me went still.

“Elias,” I whispered.

Our fifth baby.
Our last one — for now.
Eternity is long.
There will be more someday.

But in that moment, holding him, feeling the warmth of him against my chest, hearing his tiny breaths…

He felt like the whole world.


Elias was barely settled in my arms when I felt it — a ripple across the bond, soft and new, like the brush of a fingertip against the inside of my mind. His presence was warm, bright, unmistakably infant‑small.

But then another ripple followed.

Sharper.
Older.
Pulling at me in a way that didn’t belong to the newborn in my arms.

I stiffened.

Lilith noticed immediately. “What?”

“There’s… another,” I said quietly. “Not a baby. A pull.”

Her eyes narrowed, not in suspicion, but in understanding. “Offspring?”

“I think so.”
And for the first time in a long time, I trusted that instinct.

I kissed Elias’s forehead, handed him gently to Lilith, and whispered, “I’ll be back soon.”

She nodded, already settling into the rocking chair with him. “Go.”

The pull led me to Willow Creek — the library, of all places. Quiet, warm light spilling through the windows, the smell of old books drifting out every time the door opened. It was almost peaceful.

Marina Connolly sat alone at a table near the back, a stack of books in front of her, her fingers tracing the edges of the pages like she was trying to absorb the words through her skin. She looked up when I approached, and something in her expression softened, like she’d been waiting for me without knowing why.

We talked for a while — about nothing and everything. Her job. Her family. Why she liked libraries. Why she felt restless lately. Why she kept feeling like something was about to change.

When the moment felt right, I asked.

She didn’t hesitate.
She didn’t question.
She just nodded, calm and certain.

And then she was mine — my next offspring.

The bond settled between us, new and fragile, but steady. She handled the transition better than most. Stronger than I expected. Clear‑headed. Grounded.

I couldn’t bring her home — the house was full, overflowing with toddlers and newborn cries and the chaos of a family finally finding its rhythm again. So I sent her to the fledglings’ house. A safe place. A good place.

I hoped she would stay.


On the walk back, the night air cool against my skin, I realized something I hadn’t been able to see before.

I knew what kind of pull it was.

I could tell the difference — newborn bond versus offspring bond, soft ripple versus sharp tug. My instincts weren’t broken. They weren’t dangerous. They weren’t slipping out of my hands.

They were mine again.

And with that clarity came another truth, one I hadn’t wanted to face:

I had been spiraling long before I fractured.

The signs were there — the jealousy, the restlessness, the way the world felt too loud and too sharp. I just hadn’t understood what any of it meant.

But now?

Now I could see it.
Now I could name it.
Now I could stop it before it ever got that far again.

I walked home with a new son waiting for me, a new offspring settling into her transition, and a quiet confidence I hadn’t felt in years.

For the first time, the future didn’t feel like something I needed to fear.

It felt like something I could build.


Lilith and Marina talked for a few minutes after I got back while I checked on Elias.

Everything felt… good.
Balanced.
Right.

By the time Marina headed out to the fledglings’ house, I was practically vibrating with leftover adrenaline and happiness. Lilith turned toward me, eyebrows raised.

“You’re in a mood,” she said.

“I am,” I admitted. “A very good one.”

She stepped closer, amused. “And what exactly are you planning to do with that mood?”

I grinned. I couldn’t help it. “I want to—”
I paused, searching for the right phrasing.
Then it hit me, and I said it with full confidence:

“—fuck like bunnies.”

Lilith blinked. “Bunnies.”

“But as bats,” I clarified, because obviously.

There was a beat of silence.

Then she laughed — that sharp, delighted laugh that always makes me feel like I’ve won something. “As bats,” she repeated, shaking her head. “You’re ridiculous.”

“Ridiculously in love with you,” I said, because apparently happiness also makes me sappy.

She rolled her eyes, but she was smiling. “Fine. Bats.”

And that was all the permission I needed.

We shifted — wings, shadows, the familiar rush of magic — and the two of us spiraled upward in a flurry of black shapes and fluttering wings. We collided mid‑air, bounced off each other, ricocheted toward the fireplace like two very enthusiastic, very poorly coordinated fruit bats.

It was chaotic.
It was undignified.
It was absolutely perfect.

At one point I’m pretty sure I chirped.
At another point she definitely bit me on purpose.
We knocked over a decorative vase.
We might have set off the motion‑activated nightlight.

But we were laughing the whole time — even in bat form, which is mostly just high‑pitched squeaking.

And when we finally collapsed in a heap of wings and shadows in front of the fireplace, shifting back into ourselves, Lilith pressed her forehead to mine and whispered:

“You’re happy.”

“I am,” I said. “I really am.”

And I meant it.

Every word.


By the time we shifted back into ourselves and stopped laughing long enough to breathe, the house felt different — lighter, warmer, like happiness had seeped into the floorboards.

Lilith was still catching her breath when she said, “We need to talk about the babies.”

I groaned and flopped dramatically on the couch. “You’re bringing up responsibility right after bat woohoo. That feels illegal.”

She nudged me with her foot. “Mateo.”

“I’m listening,” I said, even though I absolutely wasn’t.

She rolled her eyes, but she was smiling. “We found them. All three.”

That sobered me — but in a good way. A steady way. The bond threads were clearer now, distinct. Elias was a warm glow. Marina was a sharp, steady hum. And the other three… I could feel them too.

She reached over to the coffee table and grabbed a notebook — an actual notebook, with tabs, because of course she had one ready. “We need to make a list.”

“A list,” I repeated, staring at her like she’d just suggested we file taxes during foreplay. “Lilith. We just ricocheted off the ceiling fan.”

“And now we’re planning,” she said, flipping to a fresh page. “Welcome to adulthood.”

I sat up, still grinning like an idiot. “Fine. But I want it noted that I’m doing this under protest and also while extremely satisfied.”

“Noted,” she said dryly. “First: Fernando. He’s human.”

“Nora’s married now,” I said. “Stable home. Good partner. Good situation. So we offer child support if they need it, but otherwise we stay out of the way.”

Lilith nodded. “Exactly. No supernatural talk. No warnings. No ‘your son might start levitating at thirteen.’”

I held up a finger. “Because he won’t.”

“Because he’s human,” she confirmed.

“Which honestly makes things easier,” I said. “One less kid I have to worry about hypnotizing the family cat.”

“That’s not a vampire power.”

“It could be,” I said. “Puberty is unpredictable.”

She ignored that and flipped the page. “Next: the other two babies are both vampires.”

“These are the first babies I’ve made outside of us,” I said slowly. “Outside the mating bond.”

Lilith’s expression softened. “I know.”

“And I didn’t know the mothers,” I added. “Not really. One night stands is… generous.”

“Very generous,” she said.

I groaned. “Okay, yes, I was a disaster. A charming disaster, but still.”

“You’ve grown,” she said, patting my knee.

“I’ve grown so much,” I said proudly. “I’m practically a responsible adult.”

“You just said you wanted to ‘fuck like bunnies but as bats.’”

“That was a responsible decision,” I argued. “We stayed indoors.”

She laughed — and that warm, fizzy happiness hit me again, the kind that made everything feel possible.

“Back to the babies,” she said, tapping the notebook. “For the vampires, we offer child support, yes, but we also need to talk to the mothers about what to expect.”

“Right,” I said. “The puberty talk.”

“Exactly.”

I cleared my throat, adopting my best serious dad voice. “So, ma’am, around age thirteen your child may begin exhibiting certain… abilities. Such as enhanced strength, heightened senses, and the occasional urge to climb the walls like a caffeinated spider.”

Lilith covered her face. “Mateo.”

“I’m being helpful.”

“You’re being you.”

“Which is helpful.”

She sighed, but she was smiling. “We’ll explain it gently. Calmly. No dramatics.”

“No bat demonstrations,” I agreed.

“No bat demonstrations,” she echoed.

We sat there for a moment, letting the reality settle — not heavy, just real. These babies were out there. They were mine. And for the first time, I didn’t feel overwhelmed by that.

I felt ready.

“Okay,” I said, leaning back against the couch. “So: child support for all. Vampire puberty talk for two. Respectful approach for Nora. Gentle approach for the single moms. No bat theatrics. No spreadsheets.”

“Lists,” she corrected.

“Lists,” I agreed. “Fine.”

And somehow, sitting there on the rug with the fireplace still crackling and the faint smell of singed bat fur in the air, planning for my offspring didn’t feel like a crisis.

It felt like a family meeting.
A weird one.
A supernatural one.
A very Lobo one.

But a family meeting all the same.



Simmers!

If you’re interested in writing and/or reading sims stories, participating in fun competitions and events, joining a friendly and welcoming community, completing legacies and challenge and earning medals, or just having a great place to discuss Sims 2, Sims 3, or Sims 4, then there is a place for you at the

Boolprop.net Forums


Discover more from Love My Sims

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

About Teresa 1157 Articles
Hi, I’m Teresa — longtime Sims player, storyteller, and pet enthusiast. I’ve been playing since The Sims 2 and love crafting legacies full of chaos, heart, and humor. When I’m not wrangling toddlers in-game, I’m reading, gaming (hello LOTRO), or hanging out with my Havanese and cats. This blog is where I share my Sims adventures, challenges, and stories that span generations — both in-game and in real life.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.